Consumer Reports - Ranges, Cooktops, and Ovens

Compare Prices on Ranges >>
Compare Prices on Cooktops >>
Compare Prices on Wall Ovens >>
See other reports >>

Ranges still rule when it comes to cooking appliances.

But a growing number of homeowners are seeking the added flexibility of a separate cooktop and wall oven, with burners or elements and ovens placed in just about any location. A wall oven can also eliminate the bending required by range ovens.

Whichever you buy, you'll find more pro-style models as once-plebeian brands climb the social ladder. But our tests continue to show that "pro" isn't necessarily a step up.

WHAT’S AVAILABLE

GE, Kenmore, Frigidaire, Maytag, and Whirlpool are the leading makers of ranges, cooktops, and wall ovens. Other major brands include Amana, Bosch, Electrolux, Hotpoint, Jenn-Air, KitchenAid, and LG, while high-end, pro-style brands include Dacor, GE Monogram, KitchenAid Pro-Line, Thermador, Viking, and Wolf. High-end offshoots of major brands now include Kenmore Elite and Pro, GE Profile and Pro, and Whirl-pool Gold.

Ranges. Freestanding ranges can fit in the middle of a kitchen counter or at the end. While most are 30 inches wide, true pro-style models span 36 inches and beyond. Mainstream models include electric and gas. Though coiltop electric ranges still offer the fastest heating and the most performance for the dollar, smoothtops—which put the elements beneath a sleek ceramic surface—have displaced all but the lowest-priced electrics at stores. You’ll also find gas-on-glass models that mount gas burners above a smooth ceramic surface. Price: about $400 to $2,000.

Pro-style models have gas cooktops and feature beefy knobs and massive, all-stainless construction. While they usually don’t include a storage drawer, more now include sealed burners and a self-cleaning oven. Price: about $4,000 to $6,000.

Cooktops. These can be electric coil, electric smoothtop, gas, or induction—a newer option with glass-covered magnetic coils that send nearly all of their heat to the pan, rather than the cooking surface. Besides quick heating, induction models offer instant response, though they’re pricey and require magnetic cookware. Brands that offer induction include Kenmore, Gaggenau, Thermador, and Viking, among others. Cooktops also offer gas-on-glass burners.

Consumer Reports
Buy The Full Report

For $5.95, you'll get a 30-day full access to our exclusive product Ratings, reviews and recommendations on thousands of products

 

Most electric cooktops are 30 inches and most gas models are 36 inches wide. Most are made of porcelain-coated steel or glass ceramic, with four elements or burners. Price: about $350 to $1,500 for electrics; $350 to $2,500 for gas; and $1,800 and up for induction models.

Wall ovens. These let you eliminate bending by installing them at waist or eye level, though you can also nest them beneath a countertop to save space. Most are electric and offer single or double ovens, self-cleaning or manual, with or without a convection setting. Width is typically 24, 27, or 30 inches. Price: $500 to more than $2,500 for double-oven models; figure on about $300 extra for convection.

IMPORTANT FEATURES

For all ranges

Nearly all now include a self-cleaning feature and—for gas models—sealed burners, which keep crumbs from falling beneath the cooktop. Spending more typically gets you a stainless-steel trim, a warming drawer, and six or more oven-rack positions. An especially useful feature: a raised edge around the cooktop to contain spills.

Oven controls are typically on the backsplash behind the elements or burners. Slide-in models eliminate the backsplash and side panels to blend into the countertop. You’ll also find lower-priced dual-fuel ranges that meld a gas cooktop with an electric oven. But even these typically cost hundreds more than electric- or gas-only ranges and haven’t improved performance in our tests.

For electric ranges and cooktops

Consider where the controls are located. On most electric cooktops, they take up room on the surface. Some electric cooktops have electronic touchpads that allow the cooktop to be flush with the counter.

Coil elements, the least expensive electric option, are easy to replace if they break. Spending $200 more will buy you a smoothtop model.

Most smoothtops have expandable or dual elements that allow you to switch between a large, high-power element and a small, low-power element contained within it. Some include a low-wattage element for warming plates or keeping just-cooked food at the optimal temperature. Some have an elongated "bridge" element that spans two burners to accommodate rectangular or odd-shaped cookware. And many have at least one hot-surface light—a key safety feature, since the surface can remain hot long after the elements have been turned off. The safest setup includes a dedicated “hot” light for each element.

Many electric ranges and cooktops have one large higher-wattage element in front and one in back. An expanded simmer range on some smoothtop models lets you fine-tune the simmer setting on one element for, say, melting chocolate or keeping a sauce from getting too hot.

For gas ranges and cooktops

Pricier pro-style gas ranges have four or more brass or cast-iron burners with very high output (usually about 15,000 Btu/hr.), along with heavy stainless-steel construction and beefy grates and knobs. But these $4,000-to-$6,000-plus ranges are often outcooked by gas and electric ranges that cost thousands less. Pro-style brands such as Dacor and Viking have also proven repair-prone in our surveys.

For range and wall ovens

A self-cleaning cycle uses high heat to burn off spills and splatters. An automatic door lock, found on most self-cleaning models, is activated during the cycle, then unlocks when the oven has cooled. Also useful is a self-cleaning countdown display, which shows the time left in the cycle.

Higher-priced models often include convection, which uses a fan and sometimes an electric element to circulate heated air. It can cut cooking time for large roasts, but you typically pay hundreds more for it. A few electric ovens have a low-power microwave feature that works with bake and broil elements to speed cooking time further. Some use a halogen heating bulb as well as microwaves. Another cooking technology, Trivection, uses thermal heating, convection, and microwaves to cut cooking time. Though very good overall, it’s very expensive.

A variable-broil feature in most electric ovens offers adjustable settings for foods that need slower or faster cooking. Ovens with 12-hour shutoff turn off automatically if you leave the oven on for that long. But most models let you disable it, while a child lockout lets you disable oven controls for safety.

Electronic touchpad controls are common, while a digital display makes it easier to set and monitor the precise temperature. A cook time/delay start lets you set a time for the oven to start and stop cooking, though you shouldn’t leave most foods in a cold oven for long. An automatic oven light typically comes on when the door opens, although some ovens have a switch-operated light. Also useful: a temperature probe you insert into meat or poultry to indicate doneness. Oven windows without a decorative grid usually offer the clearest view, though you may welcome the grid to hide pots and pans if you store them in the oven.

HOW TO CHOOSE

Flexibility is the biggest reason to trade the usual range for a cooktop and wall oven. But while you can get an electric cooktop and wall oven for as little as $1,300 or so, you’ll find top-performing electric and gas ranges for less than half that amount. Some other shopping tips:

Consider your fuel. Electric elements tend to heat faster and maintain low heat better than gas burners. But a gas flame makes it easier to see the heat level. Either is capable of fine performance.

Consider your cooking. If you often cook for a crowd, look for at least one high-powered element or burner and a large oven. You’ll find more midpriced gas ranges with the ultrahigh heat once exclusive to professional-style stoves. High-heat burners can be useful for searing, stir-frying, or heating large quantities. Range and wall ovens that excelled in broiling produced well-seared, evenly cooked burgers in our tests.

Balance convenience and durability. Electric smoothtops are relatively easy to clean but require a special cleaner and can be damaged by dropped pots and sugary liquids. Coiltops are tougher, but they require more cleaning time.

Keep high-tech in perspective. Ranges with special baking modes may not outperform conventional models. While touchpad oven controls are more precise than knobs, front-mounted versions are easy to bump and reset by accident; be sure they’re well-placed and visible while cooking. And while induction cooktops take the cake for quick heating, most begin at nearly $2,000.

Copyright © 2003-2007 Consumers Union of U.S., Inc.

For the latest information on this and many other products and services, visit www.ConsumerReports.org.

Compare Prices on Ranges >>
Compare Prices on Cooktops >>
Compare Prices on Wall Ovens >>
See other reports >>
Subscribe today >>

Consumer Reports Ranges - Consumer Reports Ovens - Cooktop Reviews