Small Town Girl by Kellie Pickler

WTF?! I Like This?!

pros: pleasant voice, an Idol debut with personality, better than expected

cons: thin voice, personality may grate, the magic isn't on every track, repetitive subjects

Best Idol Album Yet

pros: Catchy, Well written and performed marvelously

cons: None

Picking Pickler isn't really so bad after all!

pros: Her personality shines through, the songs are enjoyable and sicere

cons: Her voice isn't perfect, a couple of songs are generic.

Can Lightning Strike Twice For American Idol: Not Quite

pros: Pickler doesn't over sing any songs. Solid production

cons: Mostly middle-of-the-road country songs.